Be intimidated by big names or famous research groups. Although editors may be able to interpret the contents of the referee report and the letter to the editor to infer smooth gradations in recommendations, the final referee recommendations on which my own paper is based are the discrete categories reported by referees. Most referee reports must ultimately lead to a decision by a jme editor not to publish the manuscript. How to write an effective referee report and improve the scientific. Here are a few suggestions for referee report writing. Response to referee reports we would like to thank the referees for their time and useful comments towards the improvement of our manuscript. The two purposes of the report is to summarize a given paper, and offer comments or suggestions to help an author improve the paper.
Instructions for referee report university of maryland. Guide for authors journal of monetary economics issn 0304. Manuscript economicskiel201544 response to referee. As you pursue a career as a professional economist, writing referee reports will become part of your usual duties. This article was originally posted on politicsblog, of the journal politics. Referee report, cover letter, ethics, conflicts of interest.
The guide is based on the chicago manual of style online. For a longer discussion of some of these issues you may wish to consult two papers. As a young assistant professor and scholar you are also very likely to receive other requests to. Had the same paper been submitted by an established mathematician, the report might well have simply been reject because the results are already in such and such papers. The young economists guide to professional etiquette. Writing a good referee report for a journal article. Most referee reports must ultimately lead to a decision by. The authors argue that performance measures based on valueatrisk var or extreme value. Journals demand more revisions, and papers have become. Forthcoming sent out fictitious applications from single individuals with five years of work. Please answer the following referee report form regarding the manuscript english level. Start your report by briefly summarising the purpose and results of the. Referee report for some fallacies of austrian economics.
The referee provided a beautiful report, not only explaining what was already known but suggesting related problems that were still open. Most likely, after having thought about the referee s comments, you will conclude that at least some of his or her points should be taken seriously. Manuscript economicskiel201544 response to referee report 1. Writing a good referee report for a journal article justice. But it can seem an unusual exercise when undertaken for the first time and it is a difficult art form to master.
Hence, whether the paper is good or not, and you think it deserves publication or not, your job is to document for. Guide for authors journal of monetary economics issn. Nearly all advanced graduate students and new assistant professors demonstrate astounding naivete in their nonsubstantive professional dealings. The task of the referee the two major components of a referee report are. This section seems perhaps bestsuited for papers grounded in economics or other disciplines such as sociology or political science. You will need to complete all the forms and answer all the questions asked by the journal. Williamson, journal of money, credit, and banking, june 2015 supplement 2, 47, pp. This book is an invaluable handbook for young economists working on. Please answer the following referee report form regarding the manuscript english level how high is the english level in this paper.
All sources used are listed in alphabetical order in a reference list at the end of the document, but before any attachments. Novelty does the research paper provide or illustrate novelty. The journals editors, readers, and authors are extremely grateful for the time and effort that our referees provide. A new book looks at the behavioural economics of sport.
Fits our mini and compact sets, or fits nicely in your pocket with a writing utensil clipped on. You probably know that custom writing uk is a thriving niche with lots of companies that simply do business. I suggest that you read her essay not only when writing sucha report but also when drafting your. All journals are slightly different but a referee request is usually made up of two parts. Hi, i am looking for someone qulaified and experience economics report writer tahnks. A guide for new referees in theoretical computer science ian parberryt department of computer science the pennsylvania state university your success as a scientist will in part be measured by the quality of your research publications in highquality journals and conference proceedings.
High quality and timely referee reports are essential to the performance of any journal. Are 251 econ 270a guidelines for referee reports the purpose of a referee report is to recommend to an editor whether a paper is suitable for publication or not, potentially after revision. University of oxford 2 87 3adelino, manuel duke university 6 36. In the classroom the teacher sometimes is not able to focus on the individual matters of each student. This lets the author and editor know you understood what the author was trying to say. When it comes to specific comments to the text, i like to include a page number and line number to specify the relevant position in the text, although counting the line numbers is pretty boring for long papers. Jfe ad hoc referees journal of financial economics. How else can the price elasticity of demand be calculated. Simon graduate school of business administration university of rochester rochester, ny 14627 u.
Imagine that the following paper has been submitted to a journal at about the level of the journal of public economics. A concise statement of the contribution of the paper to the literature. In interviews you can gather information, pick up quotes, and set scenes the basics you need to write a story. An equivocal recommendation is acceptable if adequate discussion is provided for the guidance of the editor or program committee. It is quite unfortunate that the journal cannot offer to fully compensate the many scholars who faithfully carry out this anonymous but critical task. Submissions are restricted to seven printed pages exclusive of references, appendices, tables and figures. In writing a report, we recommend that you divide your comments into the following sections. Jfe ad hoc referees the data below covers the period 112019 through 12312019.
I read referee reports that list a bunch of questions and suggested changes. The two purposes of the report is to summarize a given paper, and offer comments or suggestions to help an author. Once a referee report is received, it is important not to take the comments too seriously. Let the editors know if you need any additional information from the authors to help you write a balanced and wellsubstantiated report. This is a guide on how to write references for various documents using the oxford style intended for footnotes with complete bibliographic information. Authors should ensure that writing is free from bias, for instance by using he or. Set the referee s report aside for a couple of days. Record your match information on these doublesided cardboard report cards. Preparing a referee report american economic association. Referee guidelines v33 american economic association. Forthcoming sent out fictitious applications from single individuals with five years of work experience.
Scan the corrected manuscript to pdf file, and upload it with this referee report form. The zero lower bound and the dual mandate, william t. Pdf writing an article for a refereed accounting journal. Also, read how to write an effective referee report and improve the. It takes all kinds of talented, bighearted volunteers to run a place like 826michigan. If the referee has indeed misunderstood your work, you have to ask yourself why he or she did so. Perhaps this is not the best way to keep an enterprise afloat.
Wellwritten replies to the points raised by referees can appropriately explain why some suggestions were not included. Econ 871 advanced international economics fall term 20 professor. Economics focus the referees an anchor finance and. You want a fair referee, you knowyou want a strong referee, anyway, and we didnt get that, grumbled sir alex ferguson, the manager. Had the same paper been submitted by an established mathematician, the report might well have simply been reject because the results are. Ive read the paper, and the paper is dealing with a different subject. Macroeconomics economics report writing research writing. When refereeing a paper, i usually receive a pdf version of a paper and then write my report separately in latex or a text file editor. One thread common to the comments on the two previous posts, on informing referees of decisions and sharing reports with other referees was the question of calibration of referee reports, and, more importantly. A good referee report has the following components. The purpose of a referees report is to provide construcove criticism on an intermediate form of a paper for an audience of two. Editorial office, journal of monetary economics william e. We draw from our experience both as editors, authors and association representatives to provide a set of guidelines for referees in preparing their reports and cover letters to journal editors.
Guidelines for your referees report faculty of arts. You need to highlight here what is new and interesting about the. I submitted a paper to a journal and got the referee report. A guide for new referees in theoretical computer science. Refer to the writing an effective scholarship essay guide for additional help. Overall, dont be afraid to have strong opinions and perhaps be wrong, but be precise throughout. How to write a referee report fa14 university of illinois. The young economists guide to professional etiquette daniel s. The task of the referee university of texas at austin. Write my essay with luciditywhile writing the essay one needs to have a book list which illustrates all originality of information the writer is using from his or her subject of research. Journal of economic perspectives, volume 6, number 1, winter 1992pages 169179. Write your report in an understandable and organized way. Daniel hamermesh, the young economists guide to professional etiquette, journal of economic perspectives 6 1992, 169179.
Here are some words of advice from quarterly journal of economics editor. In the first referee report the same surname has been repeated 10 times, and since then the referee has insisted on a discussion about that paper. Please let me know at least a week in advance which paper you have. You must complete a referee report about a paper that is yet unpublished this excludes papers that are forthcoming in a particular journal. But i send it to the editor back, briefly explaining that it was handed to me by my advisor. As an editor, i like to see referee reports comprising three sections. How should grad students approach writing a referee report. Those referees in sports andor events are the ones who make sure that all the rules of the game are adhered, obeyed, or followed by the players or participants, whereas the referees in businesses or any application are those who are appointed to examine or assess ones work, skills, behavior, and characteristics. All journal information and instructions compiled in one document pdf in just. Two referee reports, due october 9th and october 30th, 30% of final grade you must write two referee reports on papers from the syllabus that we have not discussed at great length in class. William thomson a guide for the young economist cambridge. Fall 2004 are 251 econ 270a guidelines for referee reports.
C9,c93,d0,h0 abstract this study presents an overview of modern field experiments and their usage in economics. Importance, significance how would you evaluate the importance and significance of the research paper. And generally speaking, the profession could certainly benefit from better writing. Harvey, and david hirshleifer drawing on insights of current and past editors of top economics and finance journals, we. We wish to thank you in advance for the thought, time and energy that will be going into the report that you are about to prepare.
Task 1 what is the midpoint method for calculating price elasticity of demand. Referee report for some fallacies of austrian economics i do not think that this article should be published by the qjae, because the author needs to extensively address and rework several issues that have been completely ignored by the author. Guidelines for your referees report in the course of this class, you will be asked to write two 2 referee reports on assigned papers that are at the working paper stage. A general summary of the paper and the contribution it makes.
You could select a working paper from a faculty member or a job market paper from a job market candidate on the market. News gathering and reporting guide getting great interviews interviews not only provide a reporter with essential information, they also add life and voice to a story. Before the article can be publishable, extensive reexamining and. Phd course in corporate finance how to write a referee report ernst maug 1 revised may 17, 2012 1 ernst maug, professor of corporate finance, university of mannheim. The impact of the earned income tax credit on the labor supply of married couples. You agonized over the job, not knowing exactly what was expected of you. William thompson, guidelines on writing referee reports, mimeo, 1998. Mar 31, 2016 writing a good referee report for a journal article. Phd course in corporate finance how to write a referee report.
1506 156 976 502 841 665 581 637 641 1290 369 431 897 1090 584 398 943 893 436 678 1484 502 890 84 1069 495 147 550 775 621 554 73 1310 1270 377 200 1260 1081 1069 1490